Psalm 23 is a familiar friend to many, and its comforting words are often recited in times of need. But how often do we stop and think about the words we are saying? As with any all-too-familiar passage, we often recite it without fully understanding the depth of the words that we are saying.
In the opening words of Psalm 23 we refer to God in a highly unusual way:
The Lord is my shepherd
God is portrayed in many ways throughout the Bible – as a King, a Judge, a Savior, and even a Rock. But in this well-known verse He is a shepherd. What exactly do we mean when we call God a shepherd? Do we mean that He takes care of all of our needs and leaves us to happily “graze in the green pastures and drink the tranquil waters”?
Incredibly, Psalm 23 is one of only two passages in the entire Hebrew Bible that refer to the Lord as shepherd.
Here’s the other:
Then he [Jacob] blessed Joseph and said, “May the God before whom my fathers Abraham and Isaac walked, the God who has been my shepherd all my life to this day, the Angel who has delivered me from all harm —may He bless these boys. May they be called by my name and the names of my fathers Abraham and Isaac, and may they increase greatly on the earth.” – Genesis 48:15-16
Notice that Jacob follows his use of shepherd by specifying that the Lord delivered him from all harm.
Jacob lived a difficult life. Unlike the independent and relatively trouble-free lives of Abraham and Isaac before him, Jacob experienced quite a lot of hardship. First, he had to flee his brother Esau who vowed to kill him after Jacob was reluctantly put in the position of deceiving his own father. Then he lived with his conniving uncle Laban who repeatedly tricked him and changed the terms of their arrangement. He then fled once again, only to have to contend with the ominous threat of Esau and his army – even having to wrestle an angel and become permanently injured as a result. Soon after this, He lost his beloved wife Rachel during childbirth. After finally settling in his homeland, his daughter Dinah was raped and he found himself in the midst of a conflict with the locals that his sons brought upon him against his will. Then he lost his most beloved son whom he thought dead for 22 years.
Jacob, himself, upon meeting Pharaoh referred to the years of his life as few and difficult (Genesis 47:9). He did not have it easy. And here, in one of the final scenes of his life, he refers to the Lord as the shepherd who acted as his own personal angel and delivered him from all harm.
Psalm 23, as well, does not describe a life of trouble-free grazing and drinking (verse 4):
Even as I walk
through the valley of the shadow of death,
I will fear no evil,
for You are with me;
Your rod and Your staff,
they comfort me.
The message of these verses is exactly what Jacob realizes at the end of his life. That even as he walked in the darkest places – losing a child, fleeing a brother who vowed to kill him – the Lord was with him.
But look at this verse 4 in Psalm 23 again. There is a deeper lesson that applies to each and every one of us who has experienced trying times.
Your rod and Your staff, they comfort me
What is the difference between a rod and a staff?
The Hebrew word for rod implies a tool for rebuke or punishment for one who is straying. For example:
Whoever spares the rod hates their children, but the one who loves their children is careful to discipline them. – Proverbs 13:24
A shepherd’s rod is the stick that he uses to occasionally strike the sheep that stray from the path.
The Hebrew word for staff that is used here, however, has a completely different connotation. The common Hebrew word for staff is mateh. This is the word used throughout scripture – as in the staff of Moses or the staff of Aaron in Exodus. But in this verse the word used is not mateh, it is mishenet. This far less common word actually means support. In other words, the Hebrew word mishenet means staff inasmuch as a staff is used for support, like a cane or walking stick.
Your rod and Your staff, they comfort me
Your punishment and rebuke of me when I strayed from the correct path – although painful – as well as your overt support and care for me, were both a comfort to me. For I know that they are both ways that you guide me – You shepherd me – through my life.
A shepherd wants to guide his sheep to greener pastures. And that is what the Lord wants for us. But when the sheep stray, He, at times, must use the rod to bring them back to where they need to be. It is all out of love and concern for the good of the sheep.
In our previous lesson we explained that based on the superscripture of this psalm, we know that David wrote this psalm while feeling distant from God and needy. Yet, if you read the words of the psalm itself, not only do we not see David calling out to God for help as he did in the other “Psalm of David” psalms, he actually declares that he is not needy at all! “I shall not want.” How does the text of Psalm 23 fit with the superscripture?
Based on what we explained above we now have an answer to this question. David recognizes that even when his life circumstances make him feel far from God, he knows that whatever challenging situation he is going through is really an expression of God’s love for him. No matter how needy he feels, he remembers that in reality, he is not needy at all because God is his shepherd.
When I sit and sing the beautiful ancient words of Psalm 23 every Shabbat I think about how the Lord is my shepherd; how He shepherds each and every one of us. Sometimes we feel the sting of his rod and at other times we feel his loving support in our time of need. Whether rod or staff, the Lord wants what is best for us. He is truly our shepherd.
The difficult and painful experiences that the Lord puts us through, together with the overt blessings of support that He bestows upon us, provide all that we need to guide us and shepherd us through our lives.
Rabbi Pesach Wolicki is Executive Director of Ohr Torah Stone’s Center for Jewish-Christian Understanding and Cooperation and is cohost of the Shoulder to Shoulder podcast