A Biblical Source for the Story of Hanukkah?

Dec 19, 2022

כָּל־קֳבֵל דִּי־חֲזַיְתָ דִּי מִטּוּרָא אִתְגְּזֶרֶת אֶבֶן דִּי־לָא בִידַיִן וְהַדֶּקֶת פַּרְזְלָא נְחָשָׁא חַסְפָּא כַּסְפָּא וְדַהֲבָא אֱלָהּ רַב הוֹדַע לְמַלְכָּא מָה דִּי לֶהֱוֵא אַחֲרֵי דְנָה וְיַצִּיב חֶלְמָא וּמְהֵימַן פִּשְׁרֵהּ׃

just as you saw how a stone was hewn from the mountain, not by hands, and crushed the iron, bronze, clay, silver, and gold. The great Hashem has made known to the king what will happen in the future. The dream is sure and its interpretation reliable.”

kol ko-VAYL dee kha-ZAI-ta DEE mi-tu-RA it-g'-ZE-ret E-ven dee LA vee-DA-yin v'-ha-DE-ket par-z'-LA n'-kha-SHA khas-PA kas-PA v'-da-ha-VA e-LAH RAV ho-DA l'-mal-KA MAH DEE le-he-VAY a-kha-RAY d'-NAH v'-ya-TZEEV khel-MA um-hay-MAN pish-RAY

Daniel 2:45

By Adam Eliyahu Berkowitz

Every Jew knows the basis for our system of holidays: They came and tried to kill us. They failed and disappeared in the sands of time. We’re still around. Let’s eat.

Indeed, Jacob’s dream of angels ascending and descending a ladder to heaven has been interpreted as describing the natural process of nations rising and falling while Israel stands off to the side, immune to this natural process and neither rising nor falling. 

The holiday of Hanukkah, on which we commemorate the victory of the Jews over the Seleucid Greeks, is no different. The Seleucids have long gone, but the the Jews are still around.

What is different about the holiday of Hanukkah is that it is the only Jewish holiday that does not have a biblical source. Or is it? According to some, there is actually a reference to the story of Hanukkah in the Bible.

The Book of Daniel takes place during the Babylonian exile. Daniel was a young Jew who was brought to the palace of Nebuchadnezzar, the Babylonian ruler, in order to serve the king.

In the second chapter of the Book of Daniel, Nebuchadnezzar has a dream which his own wise men are not able to interpret. He ultimately turns to Daniel for its interpretation. The dream was of a statue whose different parts were made of different materials. At the end of the dream, a stone is hewn from a mountain which strikes the statue, crushing all of its various parts. The stone then becomes a mountain that fills the whole earth.

Daniel explains that the different parts of the statue represent different world powers who will rise up and ultimately be defeated. The rock cut from the mountain which then fills the whole earth symbolizes the kingdom of Israel and the rule of the Messiah. 

Daniel himself identifies the first kingdom, represented by the head of the statue, as the kingdom of Babylon (Daniel 2:37-38). But the three other kingdoms described in the prophecy are not identified. One is represented by the silver front and arms; the second is represented by the belly and thighs of brass; the third is represented by the legs of iron and its mixture with clay. Together with the kingdom of Babylon, these are the four kingdoms that will subjugate the Children of Israel until the time of redemption.

The sages suggest that the second part of the statue represents the kingdoms of Media and Persia, the third is Greece, and the fourth kingdom is Edom, which most rabbinic sources identify as Rome. 

The medieval commentary known as the Ibn Ezra interprets this differently, including Rome within the third kingdom, presumably because of the similarities between Rome and Greece. He then identifies the fourth kingdom as Yishmael, which most sources identify as Islam.

The theory that Rome was the fourth and final kingdom that will reign before the rise of the Jewish people has a serious flaw. The fall of the fourth kingdom is supposed to usher in the Messianic era, but Rome has come and gone and the Messianic era has yet to begin. 

Some rabbis continue to maintain that the fourth empire was hinting to Rome, explaining that Christianity is an extension of Rome. This is understandable as Christianity began in Rome, and the original Christian empire still exists in the Vatican.

Modern commentators, however, understand the vision of Daniel differently. They explain that the four kingdoms refer to Babylonia, Media, Persia, and Greece. Daniel’s vision, which predicted the the oppression of the Jews by different kingdoms, ended with reign of the Greek Seleucids. 

This interpretation lends greater importance to the story of Hanukkah, suggesting that the Messianic era could have begun after the successful revolt of the Maccabees! However, the Hasmonean dynasty ultimately became wicked and did not merit the Messianic era. 

This understanding is based on the Jewish concept that the Messiah can come in every generation if that generation merits it. This idea is encouraging and also leaves us with a great responsibility. Since the Messiah can come at any time, each person is responsible for doing his utmost to bring about his arrival. 

Spread the love