Hot Take: Eden Is Not the Paradise We Should Yearn For

November 22, 2026
Wildflowers bloom against the backdrop of a sunset in the Golan Heights, northern Israel (Flash 90/ Michael Giladi))

In Israel, many kids spend their Sabbath afternoons at a club called Bnei Akiva (Pronounced Be-nay – Akeeva). Think of the Boy Scouts or Girl Scouts, but built around the Bible and a deep love for the Land of Israel. The kids sing, play group games, learn Scripture and look out for one another. It’s incredibly low tech, and a significant rite of passage for Israeli youth. Their motto is just two words: Torah v’Avodah, “Torah and Work.” In other words, faith that rolls up its sleeves. Every year, when the ninth graders move up into the older teen division, the movement gives them a name of their own. That name becomes their tribe. A teenager in Jerusalem and a teenager in a tiny desert town down in Southern Israel now share it with every other ninth grader across the country. In Israel, “Which tribe are you?” is how people place each other, the way Americans might ask what year you graduated high school. The names are never random. Each one captures something about its moment in Israel’s story. A few years ago, a tribe was named Hineni, “Here I am,” the words Abraham spoke when God called him. In 2024, a tribe was named Chaim, “Life,” in memory of Rabbi Chaim Druckman, the movement’s beloved spiritual leader. Ask an Israeli grandmother which tribe she belonged to, and watch her face light up. Her tribe’s name tells you who she is, and the Israel she grew up in.

This past Saturday night, it was this year’s turn. As the Sabbath ended, ninth graders gathered in clubhouses and courtyards from the hills of the Galilee to the Negev desert, the same land where Abraham pitched his tent, where David sang his psalms, and where the prophets promised the Jewish people would one day return. They sang. They danced. They threw their arms around each other’s shoulders.

Then the room went quiet, and the new Tribe name rang out.

Kedem.

It is a word straight from the opening chapters of Genesis. To understand why it was chosen, and why it matters for all of us, we have to go back to the gates of the Garden of Eden.

Kedem is a Hebrew word that means “of old” or “ancient.” It can also mean “east.” When Bnei Akiva’s leader, Yigal Klein, spoke to the new tribe, he ended with a verse many Jews know by heart. It comes from the Book of Lamentations, a heartbroken poem over the destruction of Jerusalem. Near the very end of the book, after five chapters of grief, the writer lifts his eyes to God and pleads:

Most of us hear “renew our days as of old” as a longing for the good old days, a golden age when life felt whole. The ancient sages heard something far more surprising. They read kedem not as a time, but as a place. And they pointed to the same word in Genesis, at the moment Adam and Eve were sent out of the Garden:

The Hebrew word for “of old,” kedem, also means “east.” So when we pray “renew our days as of old,” the sages hear a surprising request: take us back east of Eden, to the place just outside paradise where we were sent away.

Why would anyone pray “not paradise”?

In 1968, Rabbi Dr. Norman Lamm, who would later serve as president of Yeshiva University, an esteemed Rabbi of his time, and who also my husband’s late grandfather, and my children’s late grand-father delivered a sermon called “East of Eden” that takes this question head on.

Everyone, he explained, carries a private Eden in their imagination: effortless wealth, instant genius, a life of fame and happiness that arrives without a drop of sweat. And then he warned:

“What the Rabbis try to tell us is that this kind of paradise which hangs on the gossamer threads of our imaginations and is glued together by the unreal cement of our wish-fulfillment, is something that is terribly dangerous, that if we try to enter it we simply fall into an endless pit. Such a gan eden is really a gehennom.”

In other words, a dream paradise like that is not heaven at all. It is hell (gehennom).

Rabbi Lamm pointed to Adam himself. Inside the Garden, Adam and Eve stumbled, blamed each other and brought a curse on the world. Only after they were sent out did their truly human story begin: they came to know each other, built a family and started creating. The real paradise, he taught, is not the one we are handed. It is the one we build with our own hands.

He saw the same truth in the Land of Israel. The dream of a land where everything comes easily never existed. The real Israel, he said, was “built brick by brick.” Swamps were drained. Cities rose out of the desert. Schools opened, and the Bible was taught one page at a time. That is what kedem means. Not a return to a flawless past, but the courage to stand outside the gate and get to work.

I think about this teaching when I look at young people all over the world today. So many of them feel a relentless push to make everything perfect. It starts with their faces, smoothed by a filter, and their bodies, measured by an app. But it does not stop there. Many are being taught to chase a perfect society, too. In that world, everything is black and white. Every person is either a hero or a villain. Say one clumsy word or ask one honest question, and you are labeled a racist or a homophobe, cut off and canceled before you have a chance to be your own person, with your own thoughts, perspective, nuance. There is no room to grow, to learn or to be forgiven.

It is exactly the Eden Rabbi Lamm warned about. The dream of a flawless world quickly becomes a nightmare. A paradise with no room for mistakes is no paradise at all. There is real progress in our time, and it deserves to be celebrated. We understand how to communicate better. Struggles that were once whispered about, like mental health, are now met with space and generosity. But we are far from perfect, and perfection was never and should never be the goal. Chasing it is how a paradise turns into a pit.

That is why this name, given to these teenagers, moves me so deeply. They did not spend their month polishing an image. They spent it building: volunteering in their towns, honoring soldiers, learning Torah and carrying it out the door into real life. That is Torah v’Avodah. That is life east of Eden.

Renew our days as of old. Not a perfect yesterday, but the strength to build a better tomorrow, brick by brick and page by page. The members of Kedem have already begun.

Sara Lamm

Sara Lamm is a content editor for TheIsraelBible.com and Israel365 Publications. Originally from Virginia, she moved to Israel with her husband and children in 2021. Sara has a Masters Degree in Education from Bankstreet college and taught preschool for almost a decade before making Aliyah to Israel. Sara is passionate about connecting Bible study with “real life’ and is currently working on a children’s Bible series.

Subscribe

Sign up to receive daily inspiration to your email

Recent Posts
Jacob’s Bed of Brawling Stones

Related Articles

Subscribe

Sign up to receive daily inspiration to your email