Grief is a universal human experience that transcends time, culture, and geography. In moments of loss, the simple act of reaching out to comfort another can be profoundly healing. This fundamental human connection—the act of one person extending compassion to another in their darkest hour—is a thread that runs through diverse cultures and religions worldwide.
In Judaism, this universal impulse has been codified into a structured practice and religious obligation known as “comforting the mourners.” This tradition is a testament to the enduring power of human empathy and the vital role of community in times of personal crisis. By examining this practice, we gain insight not only into Jewish customs but also into the broader human need for connection and support in the face of loss.
The practice of comforting mourners is deeply rooted in Jewish tradition, and is learned from God’s own actions.
The sages understand this verse to mean that God comforted Isaac in his grief over the death of his father, Abraham. This act established a divine precedent for the commandment to offer comfort to mourners.
Jewish sages have long emphasized the importance of this commandment. The Talmud considers comforting mourners one of the greatest commandments, as it emulates God’s actions. Rabbeinu Yonah, a medieval rabbi, views it as a fundamental act of kindness, reflecting divine attributes which we are encouraged to emulate.
However, there’s nuance in how this commandment is categorized. While some see it as a biblical command, Maimonides (Rambam) in his legal code classifies it as a rabbinic obligation. This distinction highlights the complexity of Jewish law and its interpretations.
Today, we see individuals who, touched by profound personal loss, transform their grief into a wellspring of comfort for others. Their stories serve as living testaments to the enduring power of this commandment, bridging millennia of tradition with contemporary realities.
Consider the story of Rabbi Leo Dee. After his wife and two daughters were brutally murdered in a terrorist attack in 2023, Rabbi Dee channeled his immense grief into a mission of solace. He has since reached out to other bereaved families, offering the unique comfort that can only come from shared experience. In doing so, Rabbi Dee is not only honoring the memory of his family, but also embodies the timeless Jewish value of turning personal tragedy into a source of healing for others.
Similarly, Miriam Peretz’s journey illustrates how ancient wisdom can shape modern resilience. Having lost two sons in military service, Miriam became a symbol of strength in Israel. She has since dedicated her life to consoling bereaved families and inspiring soldiers, her efforts so impactful that she was awarded the Israel Prize for her contributions to strengthening the Israeli spirit. Miriam’s story shows how the practice of comforting mourners can extend beyond individual acts to influence and uplift an entire nation.
In Jewish tradition, comforting mourners involves more than words; it’s about presence and shared experience. Some key practices include:
- Shiva visits: During the seven-day mourning period, community members visit the mourners’ home, offering silent support or engaging in conversation about the deceased.
- Avoiding greetings: Visitors typically enter silently, waiting for the mourner to initiate conversation.
- Listening: Allowing mourners to express their grief freely is often more valuable than trying to offer solutions or explanations.
- Practical help: Providing meals, helping with chores, or assisting with arrangements can offer tangible support.
- Continued support: The Jewish mourning process extends beyond shiva, with various observances throughout the first year. Ongoing community support is crucial during this time.
The mitzvah of comforting mourners goes beyond individual acts of kindness. It represents a cornerstone of Jewish communal life, embodying values of empathy, solidarity, and mutual responsibility. This practice creates a support network that sustains individuals through their darkest times and strengthens the fabric of the community – touching people from all walks of life.
The Israel365 Charity Fund is dedicated to strengthening and supporting the people of Israel who need our help, including those who have lost loved ones. Donate to the Israel365 Charity Fund today.
