The Hebrew Paradox

In the entire Hebrew Bible, only two individuals receive the specific designation Ivri – Hebrew. Not Moses, not David, not Isaiah. Only Abraham and Joseph carry this loaded title, a word that literally means “one who crosses over” or “one who passes through,” derived from the Hebrew root ע-ב-ר (ayin-bet-resh).

But the Sages saw something deeper in this designation. The word Ivri signals radical separation – the courage to stand alone when the entire world moves in the opposite direction. The Sages explain that Abraham was called a Hebrew because “The entire world was on one side and he was on the other side.” This is the Hebrew – someone willing to resist all societal pressure, to cross over from the world’s way to God’s way, even when it means facing universal opposition. Yet Abraham and Joseph – the only two men explicitly called Hebrews – were the most universalistic figures in all of Scripture. Abraham became “a father of many nations,” while Joseph saved the entire ancient world from famine, mastering every language and culture of his time.

How can the Bible’s greatest universalists be marked by a title that emphasizes separation from all humanity?

This tension lies at the very heart of the Zionist movement, beginning with its founder, Theodor Herzl. On one level, Zionism appears to be the ultimate expression of Jewish particularism – a nationalist movement dedicated to gathering the Jewish people from across the globe and establishing them in their own homeland. Jews returning to their own land, speaking their own language, governing themselves according to their own laws. What could be more separatist than that?

Yet Herzl himself insisted that this Jewish particularism served a far grander purpose. From his diary’s very first entry, he declared that “God would not have preserved our people for so long if we did not have another role to play in the history of mankind.” The Jewish state, he proclaimed, was “a world necessity.” In his vision, whatever Jews accomplished “for our own welfare, will react powerfully and beneficially for the good of humanity.” Jewish suffering, he believed, “must have another meaning – a yearning after justice, after humanitarianism, must be in us and we must satisfy it.”

While Israel may be for the Jews, it ultimately exists for all of humanity.

To understand why Abraham and Joseph are the only ones referred to as Hebrews, we must grasp what the Almighty intended when He called Abram out of Ur of the Chaldees:

The order of this command is intentional. First comes separation – “go forth” from everything familiar, and separate yourself from the dominant culture. Then comes blessing – “I will bless you.” Finally comes universal impact – “all the families of the earth shall be blessed through you.” The sequence reveals everything: separation precedes universal blessing, not the other way around.

The Sages capture this principle in explaining Abram’s name change to Abraham: “At first he became a father to Aram only, but in the end he became a father to the whole world.” Abraham’s particularism – his willingness to stand alone against an entire civilization of idol-worshipers – was not the enemy of his universalism. It was its prerequisite.

Joseph’s story follows the same trajectory. Sold into slavery, imprisoned for righteousness, separated from his family for decades, Joseph underwent the most brutal form of isolation imaginable. Yet this separation prepared him for his universal mission. When Pharaoh needed someone to save Egypt and the known world from famine, he chose the Hebrew man who had fought to maintain his distinct identity in Egypt even as he mastered every language and custom of his host nation.

The Ivri stands apart not from arrogance but from assignment. God requires certain individuals to cross over from the comfortable consensus of their generation to establish new realities that will eventually bless all nations. The Hebrew stands apart to stand for everyone. This is why Abraham and Joseph – history’s greatest bridge-builders – first had to become history’s most pronounced boundary-makers.

The designation Ivri belongs to those who understand that serving all nations sometimes requires standing against all nations. Abraham separated from his father’s idol-worship to introduce monotheism to humanity. Joseph withstood the temptations of Potiphar’s wife and Egyptian paganism to become the instrument of salvation for both his family and his captors’ civilization. Each man’s separation from the world became the foundation for his service to the world.

Critics who see Jewish particularism as selfishness miss this truth: the Hebrew does not separate from humanity but rather separates for humanity – accepting the lonely burden of crossing over first so that everyone can later follow. The Ivri creates the path that will eventually lead the world itself to cross over into redemption. As Herzl wrote, “The Zionist ideal does not negate the humanist idea of the love of humanity; it includes it. But we do not want to be cosmopolitans without an identity, but to assert our nationalism while cultivating the highest principles of humanism… We want to be loyal to ourselves; then other people will believe in us more.”

This is why the State of Israel matters. This is why Jewish distinctiveness endures. Today, Israel stands set apart from other nations – attacked militarily by its neighbors and condemned diplomatically by nations across the world. The Ivri designation continues to mark us, for it remains our destiny to be separate, to be Hebrews. But this separation is not our final destination. The Hebrew crosses over first to create the path for others to follow. Ultimately, the world will join us under the sovereignty of the one true God.

Why does Iran obsessively hate Israel? Join Rabbi Elie Mischel on Thursday, July 10 at 8:00PM IDT for a powerful webinar uncovering the spiritual roots of Iran’s war on the Jewish State. Discover how ancient prophecies about Ishmael and Esau reveal the deeper meaning behind today’s headlines—and why Israel’s victories matter more than ever. Based on his eye-opening book The War Against the Bible, this event will change how you see the Middle East. Register here!