Prophet in Manhattan: How Emma Lazarus Saw Israel’s Future

On a cold winter morning in 1882, New York’s literary elite gathered in shock to read the latest work of their beloved Emma Lazarus. The woman whose poetry had enchanted Ralph Waldo Emerson and whose salon conversations had captivated Henry James had just published something utterly unexpected – a thundering prophetic call for the Jewish people to return to Jerusalem.

“The Spirit is not dead!” her verses proclaimed, echoing Ezekiel’s ancient vision. “Where lay dead bones, a host of armed men stand!” Fourteen years before Theodor Herzl would dream of a Jewish state, and sixty-six years before Israel’s rebirth, this American poet was already seeing visions of Jewish restoration that would transform both her Jewish and Christian readers.

The prophecy seemed to come from nowhere. Here was a woman who had grown up celebrating Christmas, who moved easily through Protestant high society, suddenly writing with the fire of an ancient Hebrew prophet. What divine hand had touched this daughter of Manhattan’s elite?

Born in 1849 to a wealthy Sephardic family that had lived in America since before the Revolution, Emma Lazarus seemed destined to dissolve into America’s Christian majority. Her father, a successful sugar merchant, belonged to exclusive non-Jewish clubs and showed little interest in his heritage. Young Emma spent her Friday evenings not at Sabbath dinners but at literary salons with Christian intellectuals, where she was often introduced as “the Jewess” – a term she initially accepted with quiet resignation.

Yet God, it seems, had other plans for this gifted poet. Walking past Newport’s abandoned Jewish synagogue in her early twenties, Emma felt an inexplicable pull. Though she initially saw only decline – describing Hebrew as a “dead language” – something stirred in her soul. In haunting verses, she wrote of “sad hearts that knew no joy on earth” and “lone exiles of a thousand years.” Like Samuel hearing God’s call in the Tabernacle, Emma was experiencing her first whispers of spiritual awakening.

That whisper became a thunderous call in the 1880s when news reached America of horrific pogroms in Russia. Forty Jews murdered, hundreds of women raped, thousands of homes destroyed – the reports shook Emma to her core. Like Ruth declaring to Naomi “your people shall be my people,” Emma embraced her Jewish identity with passionate conviction.

Her subsequent poetry collection, “Songs of a Semite,” stunned America’s literary establishment. With the authority of biblical prophets, she called:

“Oh for Jerusalem’s trumpet now, To blow a blast of shattering power, To wake the sleepers high and low, And rouse them to the urgent hour!”

These were not mere poetic flourishes. In an age when Reformed Judaism was rejecting the very idea of Jewish nationhood, Emma established the Society for the Improvement and Emigration of East European Jews, aimed at resettling persecuted Jews in their ancient homeland. Her vision was remarkably similar to what would emerge decades later in modern Israel.

For Christians today, Emma’s prophetic voice carries special significance. Her verses directly paralleled biblical prophecies about Israel’s restoration that many Christians now see fulfilled in the modern state of Israel. In “The New Ezekiel,” she wrote:

“I open your graves, my people, saith the Lord, And I shall place you living in your land.”

Yet Emma also challenged her Christian readers to confront uncomfortable truths. Having moved in Christian society all her life, she spoke with unique authority about Christian antisemitism. In “The Crowing of the Red Cock,” she asked:

“When the long roll of Christian guilt Against his sires and kin is known, The flood of tears, the life-blood spilt, The agony of ages shown, What oceans can the stain remove, From Christian law and Christian love?”

These words, though challenging, anticipate modern Christian efforts to confront historical antisemitism and support the Jewish people. Emma’s critique came from intimate knowledge of Christian culture, making it all the more powerful.

Her most famous words would later grace the Statue of Liberty: “Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free.” But her deeper legacy was as a prophetic voice, calling for the restoration of Israel decades before it seemed possible.

Tragically, Emma died of cancer in 1887 at just 38 years old. Her family, embarrassed by her embrace of Judaism, tried to dismiss it as a mere “phase.” History would prove otherwise. Her vision of Jews returning to their homeland would become reality with Israel’s establishment in 1948. Her call for Christians to confront antisemitism would find echo in post-Holocaust Christian theology.

For Christians today, Emma Lazarus stands as a remarkable witness to God’s faithfulness to His covenant people. Despite centuries of persecution and pressure to assimilate, He continues to call Jewish people back to their heritage and homeland. Her life demonstrates how God can work through unexpected prophets to declare His unchanging purposes.

Perhaps most remarkably, she foresaw the central role Christians would play in supporting Jewish return to Israel. Today, as evangelical Christians stand as Israel’s strongest supporters in America, they are fulfilling a vision this Manhattan prophetess glimpsed in the 1880s – of Christians and Jews working together to fulfill ancient biblical promises.

Emma Lazarus died before seeing her prophecies fulfilled. But in her short life, this unlikely prophet laid the groundwork for the Christian-Jewish cooperation that would help birth and sustain the modern state of Israel. Her story reminds us that God’s prophetic voice can speak through anyone He chooses – even a Manhattan socialite who found her way back to her people’s ancient faith and future hope.

After Hamas terrorists slaughtered over 1,200 Israelis on October 7, an unholy alliance of Islamic jihadists and progressive activists joined together to fight an unholy war against the Bible. In The War Against the Bible, Rabbi Mischel offers a prophetic perspective on these dramatic events through the words of the Hebrew Bible itself. If you yearn for spiritual clarity amid today’s turbulence, let the power of the Hebrew Bible’s prophecies and call to action strengthen your faith. Click here to get your copy of The War Against the Bible: Ishmael, Esau and Israel at the End Times now!